1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. Mastering
Mastering

Mixing vs mastering: who does what, and when you need each

Mixing decides how the instruments sit together. Mastering decides how the track sits in the world. They are two different jobs, and it pays not to confuse them.

By Angelo Pillon 4 min read
In short
  • Mixing works on the individual tracks: levels, stereo position, EQ, dynamics, effects and automation, until you have a stereo file.
  • Mastering works on the finished stereo file: tonal balance, density, loudness, true peak and consistency between tracks, then it prepares the files for every destination.
  • Stem mastering sits in between: a few groups of tracks, more control than stereo mastering, far less work than a full mix.

Many producers write to me saying “I need mastering” when what they really need is a mix, and some ask for a mix when their track is already balanced and only needs finishing. It is not a question of names: these are two jobs with different goals, tools and timelines. Understanding the difference saves you money and revisions.

Mixing: decisions about individual elements

A mix starts from the separate tracks: vocal, kick, bass, synths, guitars, effects. Every element has its own channel and its own space. The decisions are many and very specific:

  • how loud the vocal should be against the beat, verse by verse;
  • where each instrument sits between left and right, and how near or far it feels;
  • which frequencies to take out of one element to make room for another;
  • how much to compress the kick, the bass, the vocal, and with what character;
  • which reverbs and delays to use, and how to automate them over time.

The result is a stereo file in which everything has a place. A good mix already sounds like a record, just a little less dense and less loud.

Mastering: decisions about the whole

Mastering takes that stereo file. You can no longer raise the vocal without raising everything around it, so the moves are global and more subtle:

  • the tonal balance of the whole track, so it sounds right on headphones, in the car, on a phone and on big systems;
  • compression and saturation for cohesion and density;
  • stereo width and low-frequency control, which must stay solid and mono compatible;
  • loudness and true peak, with a limiter that catches the peaks without crushing the groove;
  • consistency across the tracks of an EP or album: perceived level, colour, gaps and fades.

Then comes delivery. A master is not just a file that sounds good: it is a WAV at the right resolution, checked after streaming encoding, possibly alongside a version for the club or for live shows.

Mixing answers the question “how do these sounds sit together?”. Mastering answers “how does this track sit next to all the others?”.

Why it is better not to do both in the same session

Whoever mixed a track has heard it hundreds of times. They know every detail and, inevitably, stop hearing some things: a vocal slightly low in the chorus, low mids building up, a hi-hat that gets tiring after three minutes. Mastering works best with fresh ears, a different listening setup and a different point of view.

That is why, even when I mix and master the same track, I separate the two in time: I finish the mix, let it rest, and master it as if it came from someone else.

What mastering cannot fix

Mastering improves a good mix and rescues a decent one. It does not transform a mix with structural problems. A few typical examples:

  • A vocal that is too quiet or too loud. If I lift it with EQ, I also lift everything that shares its frequencies.
  • Too much reverb. It cannot be removed from the stereo file without affecting everything else.
  • Kick and bass cancelling each other. A phase problem between two elements has to be solved at the source.
  • A resonance on a single instrument. I can reduce it, but I will also hit the other elements in that range.

In these cases it is better to fix the mix, or to move to stem mastering.

Stem mastering, the middle ground

With stem mastering you send me groups of tracks, usually four to eight (I accept up to 40): drums, bass, vocals, music, effects. I work as in mastering, but I can act on one group without touching the others. It is the right solution when the mix almost fully convinces you and only a couple of elements need fixing: the vocal needs to come forward by a dB, the bass is too wide, the cymbals are harsh.

What do you need?

  • You like the mix and just want it finished: mastering.
  • The mix works but one or two elements are out of place: stem mastering.
  • The balance does not convince you, or you only have the tracks: mix and master.
  • The vocal needs tuning, timing or cleaning: mix and master, because tuning is already part of the mix.

If you are not sure, send me the track with a couple of lines on what bothers you: I will tell you, with no obligation. And before sending anything, have a look at the guide to exporting your tracks.

Mastering from $60, stem mastering $100, mix and master from $110. The same prices as my Fiverr profile, and mix feedback costs $45.

Start a project