1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. Music
Music

Why some songs sound louder than others on Spotify

There is a switch that decides how loud each track plays. It is called normalisation, and it is almost always on.

By Angelo Pillon 4 min read
In short
  • Spotify brings all tracks to a similar average level, -14 LUFS on the normal setting.
  • Premium subscribers can choose Loud (-11 LUFS), Normal (-14) or Quiet (-19), or switch normalisation off.
  • Apple Music uses a lower level, -16 LUFS.
  • A song can still sound louder or quieter because of how it was mastered.

You are listening to a playlist, a song ends and the next one starts: suddenly it sounds quieter, or louder, or “smaller”. You reach for the volume. A few years ago this happened all the time; today far less, thanks to a technology almost nobody knows about: loudness normalisation.

In this article I explain how it works, why the differences do not disappear completely and what it means for music makers.

VU meter bridge on an API console with EQ modules
VU meters on a console: for decades this is how level was measured. Today platforms use LUFS. Photo: autore sconosciuto, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

A bit of history: the loudness war

Between the nineties and the early 2000s, many labels started asking for ever louder masters. The reason was simple: at the same volume setting, a louder song seems better, fuller, more energetic. On radio, in shops, in CD changers, the louder song won.

To raise loudness, masters were compressed and limited more and more. The result: squashed songs with no dynamics, tiring to listen to for long. It became known as the loudness war.

What LUFS are

LUFS measure perceived loudness, not peaks. A peak meter tells you how high the signal goes at its loudest point; LUFS tell you how loud the song seems to the ear on average, taking into account how hearing perceives different frequencies.

Platforms use them to turn down tracks that are too loud and, in some cases, turn up quiet ones. That way you move from one song to the next without touching the volume.

How it works on Spotify

Spotify measures the track when it is uploaded but does not change it: it adjusts the volume while you listen. For albums it uses a single value for all tracks, so quieter songs stay quieter as the artist intended. The web player and many third-party devices, such as TVs and speakers, do not apply normalisation.

Setting Level
Loud -11 LUFS
Normal -14 LUFS
Quiet -19 LUFS

Tracks louder than the chosen level are turned down. Quieter ones are turned up only as far as their peaks allow; on the Loud setting, Spotify also uses a limiter.

The other platforms

Apple Music normalises to -16 LUFS with Sound Check, on by default on recent devices. The same song can sound a little quieter than on Spotify.

YouTube turns down tracks louder than about -14 LUFS, but does not turn quieter ones up.

Tidal uses a level similar to Spotify and works per album.

Small analogue VU meter with batteries for scale
A small VU meter: perceived loudness is not the same as peaks, and that is exactly what LUFS measure. Photo: Retired electrician, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

So why do I still hear differences?

The master. Two songs at the same average level can sound different: a heavily compressed one seems “fuller” but less alive, a dynamic one more open with stronger hits.

The genre. A ballad and a techno track have different frequency content, and the ear perceives them differently even at the same level.

The platform. Apple Music normalises to -16 LUFS, so the same song can sound a little quieter than on Spotify.

Your settings. If you switched normalisation off, or use the web player, tracks play at their original level.

Devices. Some speakers and TVs do not apply normalisation.

Normalisation ended the loudness war. The winners were those with a well-made master.

What it means for music makers

You do not need to crush the master to make it seem louder. If it is too loud, the platform turns it down, and you risk losing dynamics without gaining level.

Nor do you need to master exactly to -14 LUFS. The right level depends on the genre: a club electronic track and an acoustic ballad have different needs. What matters is that the song sounds good, with impact and breath, and holds up next to references in its genre.

True peak matters. When the platform converts the file to a compressed format, peaks can rise slightly. I work with a true peak limiter and stop between -0.3 and -0.2 dBTP: safe, and no loudness wasted.

If you want to try, measure a track with my free LUFS meter. If you make music, the article how loud should your master be explains how to choose the right level.

Frequently asked questions

Should I turn normalisation on? For mixed playlists, yes: you avoid volume jumps. For an album, album mode keeps the differences the artist intended.

Why do some old songs sound quieter? They often have more dynamic, less compressed masters. At the same average level they can seem less “full”, but they breathe more.

Does normalisation reduce quality? No. It only changes the volume, as you would with the knob.

Does your song sound quieter than the others in a playlist? It is almost always solved in mastering. Get in touch

Sources